"The technology is here or will be; we must use it because it is there; we will become the kind of people the technology requires us to be; and whether we like it or not, we will remake our institutions to accommodate the technology."
-Neil Postman, Some New Gods that Fail
As did most of my MAC colleagues, I was just approaching adolescence when the internet was beginning to boom. Coming from parents who were a little slower than most to catch the technology wave, I can remember spending friday nights at my best friend's house IM chatting with kids I'd never met before. My parents would have been very concerned. But, we finally did get the internet - dial-up that is - and eventually, I got a cell phone (as a High School graduation present).
Six years later, my 6th grade cousin has her own cell phone - a pink razor that is - and it's constantly superglued to her ear when she makes the 10-block hike to and from school. How ever would her mother get ahold of her if she did not have one?
But I do not criticize my cousin for making this investment for her daughter. To not have done so would be completely out of the norm in our culture. I'm quite sure that without the gadget, my middle-school cousin would be a social outcast, and her mother would be looked at by other parents as being "behind-the-times" or "unconcerned" about her daughter's whereabouts.
As Postman points out in his article Some New Gods That Fail, bringing the highest technology into America's classrooms has become a hot(t) topic for debate among educators. He asks the important question: Is technology serving our children by fostering a more effective environment in which they can learn, or is it merely a crutch they use to avoid traditional disciplines of learning? Does the use of computers in the classroom encourage students to become effective members of a larger society or does it promote individual learning and unhealthy independence?
The introduction of the wiki into the modern classroom has opened the door for students to work together on a project without actually having to meet to discuss anything. Instead of meeting afterschool and fostering healthy, HUMAN interaction, students can go home, get on their own personal computer, blast the radio, sit down and begin "group" work in front of a computer screen. This is a whole new form of social interaction - a virtual group work. And though I see the potential effectiveness for this type of collaboration in an increasingly global society, I'm not convinced that schools should be promoting work habits that by nature foster isolation. We should keep in mind that though technology can be useful, we are treading dangerous ground when it begins to rule us and change our entire mode of interaction.
Let us keep in mind the needs of children, their social development, and their identity formation and let us choose assignments that pay heed to these factors.
Thursday, July 19, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
¡pues Emily no te quejes porque yo puse el vínculo para elmundo.es hace mucho tiempo!
I feel very strongly about the point you mentioned about technology having the potential to discourage old-fashioned face-to-face interaction between students. There are few students today emerging from our schools who are unacquainted with the internet and other forms of technology. But many young people are squeamish about public speaking, afraid to have disagreements and work through problems verbally with others, unable to hold conversations about serious issues, and lacking in social skills (especially the ability to interact with adults and the elderly). It might sound negative, but I really believe that these skills are essential if people want to have healthy relationships with the people around them and be active members of society.
~P.S.H
I agree that we should have some concern regarding how these new gadgets will affect the social skills of the tech generation, but I think they'll find their way. All of this technology did not come about for me until the end of college so I have not been influenced by the web for the majority of my life. I do recall though that my parents worried that ATARI would have the same negative consequences on me and their parents worried about TV.
I think your point is very valid and I have to admit to my own fears about the potential for the "downfall of all human interaction". On the other hand, I wonder if we can view this as a generational issue. Just as our parents worried about our TV habits and whether to install a telephone in our bedrooms, we have issues with children today using cell phones and the internet. Perhaps we should try to see the situation from that perspective and do as our parents did with us: set limits, clarify, and help young people make informed choices for their lives.
Post a Comment